On the Western Front – Part 2. The Battle of Messines Ridge

This is my second post on the World War I battlefields where my grandfather Will Mathers (1893-1953) served from 1916-1919 (the first is here). After recovering from being gassed, and then some leave, Will and Tom went to the Messines Front on 20 November 1917 and ran a dressing station at Bailleul until mid December. Bailleul was 13 km west of Mesen, in French Flanders, just 3 km from the Belgian border.

The Messines Ridge extends south from Ypres almost to the Belgian border and was captured by German forces in 1914. The ridge granted the German Army a dominant position overlooking the Ypres salient. Before launching their offensive at Passchendaele in September 1917, the Allies planned to capture the Messines Ridge.

The battle of Messines, at Wijtschate and Mesen, was notable for two things. The Allied attack was preceded by the detonation of a million pounds of explosives packed into 21 mineshafts under the German positions along the entire 15km length of the Messines ridge. The colossal explosion in the early hours of Thursday 7 June 1917 was heard as far distant as London (where Lloyd George is reputed to have heard it from his offices in Downing Street) and Dublin.

Troops on the rim of one of the Messines mine craters, probably Peckham, shortly after the battle.

The two most northerly positioned mines on the Messines ridge exploded on Hill 60 (24,000 kg of explosives) and at the Caterpillar (32,000 kg of explosives), which is just across the railway tracks from Hill 60. The tunnel dug to place the explosives was 700 metres long. The mines left deep and wide craters that are there still today.

Hill 60 Crater
Caterplillar Crater

. Although 10,000 casualties were reported on 10 June, 21 days after the explosion, the historian, Simon Jones, challenged the death toll of the mines using primary sources and suggested that the mine explosions killed no more than 500 German troops and that 7,344 were taken prisoner. The report of 10,000 casualties originated from the German estimates for total casualties (including prisoners) in the Battle of Messines.

Messines Ridge British Cemetery at Mesen in Flanders

The battle, and the taking of the town of Mesen (Messines in French) on a very hot summer day, was one of the few British and Allied ‘triumphs’ in Flanders. Although it was successful, a meagre advance was tempered by the loss, among the Allied troops, of 6800 Australians. By the end of the day Private John Melrose (aged 29) was among the dead. He is remembered on the Ypres memorial (panel 127) at the Menin Gate. Shortly afterwards the 36th was in action again, this time at Passchendaele.

Menin Gate, Ypres
Panel 127 on the Menin Gate, Melrose J recorded lower right column,

John Melrose (1887-1917) and William Melrose (1989-1917) were cousins of Will and Tom, who had emigrated to Australia in 1909 and 1911 respectively. They both enlisted in 1916, John only two weeks after he married Annie Lennox, another young immigrant from Scotland.

Will and John Melrose

John joined the 36th Australian Infantry Battalion, nicknamed “Carmichael’s Thousand,”and took part in the Battle of Messines. Assigned to the 9th Brigade, the battalion fought on the Oostaverne Line and suffered heavily.

The Red Cross wrote several letters to Annie. In a letter dated 1 March 1918, the report of a Private Jeffery states:

“I was personally acquainted with No. 2611 Pte Melrose,J. 36th Battalion.  On the night of 7th June 1917 Pte. Melrose and I were part of a carrying party working between Ploegstreet Wood and firing line. About half way towards the firing line on our fourth trip an enemy machine gun opened fire.  No. 2611 Pte. Melrose was hit in the head and killed.  He was buried next morning about 100 yards from where he fell.”

John must have survived the attack on Messines Ridge (they started in the early hours) only to be killed when the victory was secured. Ploegsteert Wood was at the extreme southern end of a 9 mile (N/S) offensive and lies just north of the French town of Armentieres (although the wood is actually in Belgium). The Wood was referred to as Plugstreet by the British troops.

A British WWI machine-gun bunker deep in Ploegsteert Wood.

John’s brother William was in the 35th Australian Infantry Battalion, which fought in the Battle of Passchedaele. He was killed on 12 October, 1917 at Passchendaele, five months after the death of his brother. In a letter dated 21 October 1918, a Private J. Morris reported:

“He stayed behind a pill box at Passchendaele and said he was going to get the German gun to use it against them. He never came back to us. A Pte. Fred Walker reported  that Sergt. Curtain told him in December that at Passchendaele on Oct. 12 1917, Melrose was killed instantly by a shell.”

Will Melrose is also remembered on the Menin Gate, mid right column,
Wild Teasel in Ploegsteert Wood

On the Western Front – Part 1. The WW1 Battlefields around Ypres in Flanders

Just over 110 years ago my grandfather William Melrose Mathers (1893-1953) and his brother Thomas (1891-1963), enlisted in the Australian Army on 2 September 1915. Being strongly opposed to killing anyone, they managed to get assigned to the 8th Field Ambulance of the Australian Medical Corps. They spent the next three and a half years on the Western Front in France and Belgium, on the front lines and at Regimental Aid Posts (RAPs) and hospitals behind the front lines.

Will Mathers (left) Will and Tom in Salisbury, 2 September, 1916

My older son went on a school trip to the Western Front battlefields in 2018 and visited battlefields where his great-grandfather had served as part of the Australian Field Ambulance. My younger son and his girlfriend both missed out on similar trips in 2021 due to the covid restrictions. So we went on a week-long trip to Flanders and the Somme to see some of the important sites on the Western Front. Our first stop was the Flemish city of Ypres and the battlefields nearby.

The medieval city of Ypres was completely leveled by artillery fire between 1914 and 1917. The city’s 13th-century Cloth Hall and St Martin’s Cathedral, seen in this photo, were reduced to rubble.

Ypres: the 13th-century Cloth Hall and St Martin’s Cathedral in 1917

After the war, some wanted to leave the city untouched as a reminder of the destruction, but the Flemish residents decided to rebuild the city faithfully reproducing the medieval buildings, including the magnificent Cloth Hall, in this photo, which houses the Museum “In Flanders Fields”.

The rebulit Cloth Hall today
This heavy 42cm artillery shell stands as a stark monument to the relentless bombardment the city endured. Shells like this were fired from a “Big Bertha” siege howitzer.
View of the rebuilt St. Martin’s Cathedral from the Belfry Tower of the Cloth Hall
Looking towards the Menin Gate.

The Menin Gate is dedicated to the British and Commonwealth soldiers who were killed in the Ypres Salient of World War I and whose graves are unknown. The names are recorded on stone panels of 54,395 Commonwealth soldiers who died in the Salient but whose bodies have never been identified or found. These include the names of 6,198 Australians. They also include the names of the brothers John and William Melrose, Scottish cousins of my grandfather William Melrose Mathers. Every night at 8 pm, the Last Post is played at the Menin Gate.

Crowd gathering at the Menin Gate for the Last Post

The Third Battle of Ypres, also known as the Battle of Paschendaele began on 31 July 1917. Massive artillery fire on the eve of the battle was intended to destroy German positions, but failed to do so. By mid-August, the first day objectives had still not been reached. A month later, the offensive resumed. New Zealanders, Australians and South Africans replaced British trooped in the spearhead of the attack.

The 8th Field Ambulance served on the Somme until September 1917, when it moved to Ypres to support the Australians. On 20 September, Will and Tom went into the front line for 48 hours to bring out the wounded on stretchers. They had a day in a rest area before going back into the front line on 23 September at Hooge.

Trenches at Hooge Crater were reinforced with corrugated iron. The pre-shaped, semi-circular corrugated iron sheets used by both Allied and German forces to construct and reinforce overhead coverings were known as “Baby Elephants”.

A trench at Hooge Crater

Hooge was the site of several large German mine craters. The lake in the photo below fills three German mine craters blown in June 1916 as part of their offensive against the Canadians.

Hooge Crater today
One of many piles of artillery shells.A baby elephant is in the background.

One of many piles of artillery shells. In the two weeks before the attack alone, 4.2 million shells were fired at the German positions. The shelling failed to dent the German defences, but it destroyed the landscape and its drainage. The poor state of the terrain made it hard to move the guns forward.

A coil of barbed wire.

Will and Tom spent 72 hours evacuating the wounded from waterlogged trenches, dug outs and shell holes. Other members of the unit worked at the RAPs under fire. The bearers at Hooge endured heavy shell fire and the unit received many casualties.

The line of low hills running east of Ypres includes Hooge, Polygon Wood and Passchendaele. The Battle of Polygon Wood (26 September to 3 October 1917) took place in woodland that had been almost totally destroyed by the huge bombardments from both sides since 16 July and the area had changed hands several times. The I Anzac Corps (under Lieutenant-General William Birdwood) conducted the main advance of about 1,200 yd (1,100 m), to complete the occupation of Polygon Wood and the south end of Zonnebeke village.

Australian infantry attack on Polygon Wood. Painting by Fred Leist 1919.
Me in a regrown Polygon Wood.
This German bunker,built in 1916, was captured by the 56th Australian Battalion on 26 September 1917.
Inside the bunker.

Will and Tom were gassed in Polygon Wood on 29 September 1917 and both became became sick. Will was hospitalized with gastritis for 8 days; Tom with a hernia of the groin was put on light duties.

Australian troops Australian infantry with small box respirator gas masks, Ypres, September 1917.
The Buttes Cemetery in Polygon Wood contains the graves of 1295 British, 50 Canadian, 564 Australian, 163 New Zealand and 30 unidentified. Only 428 of these could be identified by name.
Overlooking the cemetery is a monument to the 5th Australian Divison, which fought here.

After walking through Polygon Wood with temperatures around 32 C, we found ourselves at the Anzac Rest where a refreshing beer was welcome.

Australian hat collection on the ceiling beams.
Felix uses a periscope in a trench at Paschendaele.
Bunker and trench at Passchendaele.

As the Battle of Passchendaele continued, more focused attacks gradually shifted the front line but the losses were huge. And the artillery bogged down in the mud. In April 1918, to reinforce lines against the massive German Spring Offensive (Operation Georgette), the British evacuated the heavily contested Passchendaele Ridge, surrendering ground that had cost thousands of lives in 1917.

The allies were back where they had been in 1914. Their well developed positions had been exchanged for a pulverised, smaller bulge where everything had to be built afresh. That captured terrain had been transformed into a moonscape and the territory gained, at just 8 kilometres, came at a high price, with an estimated 600,000 casualties, including more than 125,000 dead. Passchendaele became an international symbol of the cruelty and futility of total war.

Tyne Cot War Cemetery, Passchendaele.

Tyne Cot is the Largest Commonwealth wall Groves cemetery in the world. There are almost 12,000 graves and a memorial wall bears the names of 35,000 soldiers who have no known grave. Most of those commemorated here died during the Battle of Passchendaele.

Tyne Cot Memorial Wall

In 1917, the site was completely barren except for German concrete bunkers with Machine gun nests. On 4th of October, the 40th battalion of the third Australian division broke through the position at Tyne cot. Over the following days, ANZAC troops tried in vain to advance from here towards Passchendaele. The bunkers on the site were converted to medical dressing station shortly after being taken. Those who succumbed to their injuries were buried at this site. This was the start of the cemetery.

Cora Minnett — pioneer SF writer and confidence trickster

In researching my Warren ancestors (see my previous post about them), I discovered that my great-great-great grandfather, James Warren (1804-1884) had a granddaughter Minnie Warren Jones, who achieved fame and infamy as a pioneering feminist science fiction author and confidence trickster.

Minnie Warren Jones, born in 1868, was the daughter of Eliza Warren (1840-1902) and James Jones (d. 1903). This account of her life (as far as it is known) and her literary career and other exploits draws heavily on the research of Steve Holland[1]. She took to the stage in 1888 using the name Cora Minnett Vane, after leaving school at age 19.

Continue reading

My Irish Palatine and German Ancestors

I have two convict ancestors who were transported to Australia from England and Ireland in the early nineteenth century. See here for the story of Thomas Wilson. My other convict ancestor, William Warren (1765-1850), came from Wexford in southeast Ireland and was my 4th-great-grandfather. His wife Eleanor Jeakle (1773-1849) remained in Ireland when her husband was transported to Australia in 1816.  I was recently updating my family tree and an Ancestry.com hint led me to a family tree which showed that Eleanor Jeakle had German grandparents who lived and died in the Rhineland-Palatinate.

Family trees on Ancestry.com often contain spurious information because people accept hints based on no more than similarities in names and dates, without checking for evidence of relationship. I researched the German grandparents and indeed found that there was absolutely no evidence of a relationship my Irish ancestors. However, in doing so, I came across a website that talked about the Irish Palatines and their emigration from Germany in 1709.  And there in a list of families who settled at Old Ross near Wexford was the name ‘Phil Jeakle’. I was astonished. The link to the Rhine-Palatinate that seemed too fantastical to be true was in fact probably true.

Continue reading

Revisiting The Hobbit movie (yes – as one movie not three)

Having recently re-read The Lord of the Rings trilogy (see my earlier post) and realizing that Peter Jackson had changed more in the movie versions than I had realized, I decided to rewatch the three Lord of the Rings (LOTR) movies for the third time, but this time in the Extended Edition, which I’ve never seen. I purchased a copy of that, which has just arrived. But I have been pondering whether to watch the Hobbit movies before watching LOTR.  I really disliked Peter Jackson’s padding out the story with made-up elements that were not in the book, and spinning it out to three overblown movies. There were some aspects I enjoyed, but I just could not bring myself to watch them again, let alone in the extended editions.

Then I stumbled across a “fan edit” of the Hobbit movies to make a single movie (of length just under 4 hours) which is reasonable faithful to the book, removes excess material and the more ridiculous action sequences. This fan edit, called “The Hobbit – The Cardinal Cut” is described here and can be downloaded or watched on Youtube.

Continue reading

My paternal ancestors’ European journey – from the Caspian Steppes to Celtiberia

In a previous post, I used an analysis of my Y chromosome DNA to trace the journey of my paternal ancestors from Y-chromosomal Adam, who lived in West Africa around 275,000 years ago (275 kya), to the founder of the R1b sub-haplogroup R-L23, who was born on the Caspian around 4,400 BC (6.4 kya). In this post, I continue my paternal ancestral journey to the most recently identified haplogroup founder: a Celtiberian living in what is now Portugal around 510 BCE. The sequence of Y SNPs defining my haplotree are shown in the following map. It summarizes this journey from R-L23 (4,400 BCE) to the most recent haplogroup founder (510 BCE), and continues on from the map published in the previous post.

There is an immense amount of recent research on European Bronze Age genetics and migrations and a very considerable unfinished debate on how to interpret the evidence. New evidence is being published almost weekly, as increasing numbers of ancient European remains are analysed and Y haplogroup identified. So this post will only aim to describe the big picture as best I can summarize it, and details and perhaps even some of the big picture will likely change in the future.

Continue reading

How long ago were the events of The Lord of the Rings?

As I discussed in my previous post, Tolkien set out to create a mythology for the English in the Lord of the Rings (LOTR), the Silmarillion and related writings on Middle-earth. He presented himself not as the author of LOTR, but as the translator of various histories written by Bilbo, Frodo and others in the Third and Fourth Age of Middle-earth. This makes Tolkien quite unusual among modern writers of fantasy in presenting it as set in the real worlc albeit in an imagined prehistory. What happened in that period before the Earth’s actual recorded history is otherwise remembered down through the generations as folk myths and legends, especially among the Old English. Tolkien’s life work was an attempt to reconstruct our prehistory, and more specifically the prehistory of the English. Critics Lee and Solopova commented that “Only by understanding this can we fully realize the true scale of his project and comprehend how enormous his achievement was” [1].

Tolkien described the region in which the Hobbits lived as “the North-West of the Old World, east of the Sea” in LOTR, ie. essentially Europe (including Britain). However, as he noted in a letter [2], the geographies do not match, and he did not consciously make them match when he was writing. In another letter [3] he became much more specific, saying “If Hobbiton and Rivendell are taken (as intended) to be at about the latitude of Oxford, then Minas Tirith, 600 miles south, is at about the latitude of Florence. The Mouths of Anduin and the ancient city of Pelargir are at about the latitude of ancient Troy.” In the Prologue to LOTR, Tolkien also notes that “Those days, the Third Age of Middle-earth, are now long past, and the shape of all lands has been changed…”

Fascinated by the detailed chronologies and calendars set out in the Appendices to LOTR and elsewhere, I have naturally wondered how long ago from now the events of LOTR took place. About 15 years ago, I came across an article in the Journal of the Tolkien Society [4¡ which deduced that the Fourth Age began on Wednesday 18 March 3,102 BCE.  The events of LOTR took place during the preceding year.  Despite the bizarre exactness of this, I was quite impressed by the argument, which I summarize here briefly.

Continue reading

The Indian Transmission of Zen Buddhism

A previous post examined the Zen tradition of “lineages” of teachers transmitting enlightenment person-to-person and documented the lineages of my Zen teachers down from Bodhidharma, the first Patriarch of Chinese Ch’an (Zen).  In this post, I examine the Zen tradition of an Indian lineage which reaches back from Bodhidharma through 27 ancestors to the the historical Buddha, Shakyamuni. Shakyamuni Buddha’s birth and death dates are somewhat contested, but 563-483 BCE seem to be the most generally accepted dates.

Continue reading

Hubble observed a supernova brighter than its galaxy

A supernova releases as much energy in days as our Sun does in several billion years. In 2018, the Hubble Space Telescope observed a supernova 70 million light years away, which outshone its entire galaxy until it faded away over the following year.

This video zooms into the barred spiral galaxy NGC 2525, located 70 million light-years away in the southern constellation Puppis. As we approach an outer spiral arm a Hubble time-lapse video is inserted that shows the fading light of supernova 2018gv. Hubble didn’t record the initial blast in January 2018, but for nearly one year took consecutive photos, from 2018 to 2019, that have been assembled into a time-lapse sequence. At its peak, the exploding star was as bright as 5 billion Suns.

While nuclear fusion and a slow neutron capture process form all the elements up to 83 (Bismuth), the elements are also produced very rapidly in supernovae along with all the heavier elements. Supernovae have produced the the bulk of the universe’s precious metals, silver, platinum and gold, and are responsible for the creation of the heaviest elements up to uranium.

Supernovae like this all peak at the same brightness and so can be used to accurately measure the distance of their host galaxy, allowing accurate measurement of the universe’s expansion rate. The current best estimate is that the universe is expanding at a rate of 69.3 km/sec/Megaparsec plus or minus 0.8. That means that for every Megaparsec (about 3 million light years) that you go out, the Universe is expanding 69.3 km/sec faster. So that means that NGC 2525 is moving away from us at a speed of around 1500 km/s or half a light year each century.

A family history mystery – who is the 2nd Annie Priscilla Wilson?

Thomas Wilson

In a previous post, I wrote about my great-great-great-grandfather, Thomas Wilson (who was transported to Australia as a convict in 1834). He had been sentenced to 7 years transportation for highway robbery. In researching his descendants, I documented a granddaughter Annie Priscilla Wilson, who was born in 1880 to his son Thomas Wilson (1847-1923) and wife Frances Oliver (1852-1893). Annie Priscilla married John Fitzgerald in Manly in 1900 and they moved to Wollongong. She died in 1964, I have seen the death certificate, and she is buried in the Wollongong Cemetery (Sect. RC Row: Nth 25 Site: 26). I have been contacted by one of her grand-daughters who has confirmed all these details.

This is where it gets interesting. In searching for information on Thomas Wilson and his family, who lived at Church Point, Pittwater north of Manly in Sydney, I came across a website with the following information. It described the rediscovery of the graveyard associated with the first St John’s Anglican Church in Mona Vale, about 5 km from Church Point, where the Wilson family lived. This church was a small weatherboard structure built in 1871 overlooking Mona Vale Beach, which was moved to a new site in Bayview in 1888.  One of the gravestones uncovered was for “Annie Priscilla Wilson Aged 2 Years (1880-1882) Dearly loved daughter of Frances and Thomas Wilson”. I have also found a photograph of the Memorial Plaque erected on the site in her memory. There is only one birth “Annie Priscilla Wilson” registered in NSW for anyone with the names Annie, Ann, Anne, Priscilla and parents Thomas and Frances Wilson in the date range 1865-1900. So this is a complete mystery. Although her gravestone has been found saying she died in 1882, she also got married to John Fitzgerald in 1900. I also cannot find a death certificate for Annie Priscilla Wilson in 1882.

Continue reading